Monday, January 08, 2007

Run for your lives!!! It's a culture of fear.

What's the next ridiculous subject that Christina can waste her energy ranting about? I'll tell you what: stupid forwards; especially the kind designed to make people afraid. The main themes I want to impress upon you guys before going into it are the following: 1) I'm not posting this to make anyone feel bad about sending me forwards. We've all been had before. 2) Start showing a little skepticism, people! Snopes.com and Skepdic.com will tell you the truth about most urban legends that float around. 3) This mainly applies to girls: use some common sense before sending a forward. Remember, we've all seen just about every single one that floats around. Before sending a forward to me or anyone else, please check it for accuracy, or make sure that it's the most hilarious thing you've ever read. Then ask yourself if I would think it's funny. I don't hate getting forwards, but they had better be good and not be something I've seen before.

Before I go lambasting, I have another disclaimer to make. When I said "we've all been had," I meant it. I have been caught on the wrong side of not performing my due diligence by the lovely and intelligent Kirsten, who pointed me to my own favorite Snopes.com for the truth on a forward that I forwarded. I learned from it and so can you.

Here's the prime offender. I've probably gotten this forward about 5 times since I started receiving email. I won't post the forward in its entirety, because it's long. It opens and closes with an appeal to all women to please read it for their own safety and forward it to everyone they know because it's a big bad world out there and everyone's out to get you. It's a list of ways to get yourself out of hostage situations if you're a vulnerable woman. It also states that it is being sent out due to the recent spate of daylight abductions that have been going on. Here's the most interesting part to me:

9. Another Safety Point: Someone just told me that her friend heard a crying baby on her porch the night before last, and she called the police because it was late and she thought it was weird. The police told her "Whatever you do, DO NOT open the door." The lady then said that it sounded like the baby had crawled near a window, and she was worried that it would crawl to the street and get run over. The policeman said, "We already have a unit on the way, whatever you do, DO NOT open the door." He told her that they think a serial killer has a baby's cry recorded and uses it to coax women out of their homes thinking that someone dropped off a baby He said they have not verified it, but have had several calls by women saying that they hear baby's cries outside their doors when they're home alone at night. Please pass this on and DO NOT open the door for a crying baby ---- This e-mail should probably be taken seriously because the Crying Baby theory was mentioned on America 's Most Wanted this past Saturday when they profiled the serial killer in Louisiana. I'd like you to forward this to all the women you know.

I was going to send this to the ladies only, but guys, if you love your mothers, wives, sisters, daughters, etc., Everyone should take 5 minute to read this. It may save your life or love one's life.

After reading this forward, I carried my browser over to Snopes.com and did a search for "baby's cry serial killer" Instantly two articles come up. One of them details the phoney origins of the story and the second thoroughly details the benefits and drawbacks to all of the advice on evading abductors. It took me three steps to find the truth on this story and decide it wasn't something to forward to people. If I had been inclined to forward things to people in the first place, that process would have taken just as many steps.

One of the things that gets me is that the article states that this has been in circulation for 5 years. 5 years! People! Do you know how many people need to neglect their googling duties for this kind of thing to go on for five years? Lots, that's how many. It kills me that in an age when we have all the answers at our fingertips, people still don't know where to go to find them. I know why people were so susceptible to this stuff before the internet invaded every home, but in today's age, it's ridiculous for people to not know how to find the answers for themselves. The other thing that really bugs me is that someone had to make up that story. They had to invent it from scratch and broadcast it with the intent of deceiving people. The thought of that really gets my goad. Every woman that gets this email gets a little pang of fear and remembers the advice for at least a little bit. She internalizes that the world is a dangerous place where she's at peril all the time, something we know is simply not true, yet is somehow broadcasted as though it is gospel all the time.

Back to the reference to skyrocketing numbers of abductions. According to this fearmongering website, there were 28,765 abductions of adults and children in 2000. Dividing by the population at the time, we find that that means that there was an abduction rate of .0001%, or put another way, you have a 1 in 10,000 chance of being abducted. And most of the time, it'll be someone you know anyway. Remember a few posts ago when I gave statistics showing that the rate of all crime except drug arrests has decreased dramatically?

Due diligence, people.

10 comments:

Jorge said...

I have noticed something that you mentioned on theme number 3! I work with a bunch of men, and my girlfriend works with a bunch of women and on the few times that I have noticed her work email it is just full of forwarded messages where I have none. I wonder why this is???

Christina said...

I don't know, maybe girls are dum or something? We just love perpetuating those forwards. Nathan never gets forwards from his buddies. It's almost like they're older than 14...

Anonymous said...

You can slam me all you want, but most of the time, guys are much more skeptical about things like that, and the girls have a greater tendency to buy into it. Just notes from personal observations.

As always, the big exceptions are the well informed, or the ones who are willing to do a little research before pulling the fire alarm. My response to every one of these that I get from friends and relatives (my gandmother in particular, as she has very limited computer experience) is to track a little background info, and send them there (places like Snopes.com).

Here's to a safer, more informed public.

Christina said...

I won't slam you, because I agree. I don't know why girls think it's so great to perpetuate these things. It sounds bigoted, but I have to be honest here and say that I don't think I've ever received a stupid forward from a guy. Ever. Sometimes I'll get one of those "funny" surveys intended to elicit a response, but never a fearmongering or ridiculously stupid one.

The day I made this post, I got about 4 forwards, all from women.

Anonymous said...

I'll forward some of the 'scare tactic' ones every once in a while, but they're always preceded with something along the lines of "can you believe people are buying this?"

My biggest pet peeve when it comes to this sort of stuff - the virus scares. HOE LEE COW... I so wish people would understand that *NO* e-mail can ever do anything to your computer. It's only if you download and open any attachments. If more people understood this, there would be so many fewer virus issues...

Knowledge is power. Be powerful.


P.S. Not that it's your fault, but lately I've had to do the word verifications twice. It's very strange...

Christina said...

Strange...I wonder why that's going on. But I agree about the knowledge is power thing. It's funny, that phrase reminds me that when you're an education major you can't use that phrase, because knowledge is the lowest form of learning on the scale. But that's just semantics. Stupid college...

Anonymous said...

I think the word verification thing has something to do with the order I fill in the posting blanks (since I change from "Google/Blogger" to "Other"). Or perhaps not (I just tried a different order of ops to no avail). Some goofy little quirk.

Not allowed to say "knowledge is power"... That's rather amusing, really. You're also right about the semantics of it. Knowledge really isn't very useful unless you can apply it, so yes, the phrase could technically be considered incomplete. Still, for too many people, just knowing something with some minimal understnading would be a great improvement.

Christina said...

http://www.coun.uvic.ca/learn/program/hndouts/bloom.html

It's actually really interesting to me. When I came upon this in probably my sophomore year, I remember thinking it was really enlightening. Still, I've always been a big fan of the value in rote memorization, despite the fact that this pretty much negates the need for it. I just think there's a time and place for rote memorization and that used in moderation it can be a fundamental building block to aid in the later stages of cognition.

Anonymous said...

Have you noticed how far too many people are too lazy or unwilling to go out and learn anything new anyway these days? They'd all rather be spoon fed by a flashing, talking box...

I think I end up with a chain of Wikipedia pages (and their references) open on a daily basis, because of something I heard, saw, or read. Granted, I doubt my instructors would be thrilled about me reading that instead of listening to them ramble.

Christina said...

I'm the same way. If I were allowed to just learn stuff all day long, I'd be as happy as a clam...oh wait, that's exactly what I get to do all day. I find out all kinds of facts. Tomorrow, it's the rave subculture, among other things.

Just the facts, ma'am.